I have the following row in a CSV file that I am ingesting into a Splunk index:
"field1","field2","field3\","field4"
Excel and the default Python CSV reader both correctly parse that as 4 separate fields. Splunk does not. It seems to be treating the backslash as an escape character and interpreting field3","field4 as a single mangled field. It is my understanding that the standard escape character for double quotes inside a quoted CSV field is another double quote, according to RFC-4180:
"If double-quotes are used to enclose fields, then a double-quote appearing inside a field must be escaped by preceding it with another double quote."
Why is Splunk treating the backslash as an escape character, and is there any way to change that configuration via props.conf or any other way? I have set:
INDEXED_EXTRACTIONS = csv
KV_MODE = none
for this sourcetype in props.conf, and it is working fine for rows without backslashes in them.
UPDATE: Yeah so Splunk's CSV parsing is indeed not RFC-4180 compliant, and there's not really any workaround that I could find. In the end I changed the upstream data pipeline to output JSON instead of CSVs for ingestion by Splunk. Now it works fine. Let this be a cautionary tale if anyone stumbles across this question while trying to parse CSVs in Splunk!
I have the following two lines of code:
json_str = _cases.to_json
path += " #{USER} #{PASS} #{json_str}"
When I use the debugger, I noticed that json_str appears to be formatted as JSON:
"[["FMCE","Wiltone","Wiltone","04/10/2018","Marriage + - DOM"]]"
However, when I interpolate it into another string, the quotes are removed:
"node superuser 123456 [["FMCE","Wiltone","Wiltone","04/10/2018","Marriage + - DOM"]]"
Why does string interpolation remove the quotes from JSON string and how can I resolve this?
I did find one solution to the problem, which was manually escaping the string:
json_str = _cases.to_json.gsub('"','\"')
path += " #{USER} #{PASS} \"#{json_str}\""
So basically I escape the double quotes generated in the to_json call. Then I manually add two escaped quotes around the interpolated variable. This will produce a desired result:
node superuser 123456 "[[\"FMCE\",\"Wiltone\",\"Wiltone\",\"04/10/2018\",\"Marriage + - DOM\"]]"
Notice how the outer quotes around the collection are not escaped, but the strings inside the collection are escaped. That will enable JavaScript to parse it with JSON.parse.
It is important to note that in this part:
json_str = _cases.to_json.gsub('"','\"')
it is adding a LITERAL backslash. Not an escape sequence.
But in this part:
path += " #{USER} #{PASS} \"#{json_str}\""
The \" wrapping the interpolated variable is an escape sequence and NOT a literal backslash.
Why do you think the first and last quote marks are part of the string? They do not belong to the JSON format. Your program’s behavior looks correct to me.
(Or more precisely, your program seems to be doing exactly what you told it to. Whether your instructions are any good is a question I can’t answer without more context.)
It's hard to tell with the small sample, but it looks like you might be getting quotes from your debugger output. assuming the output of .to_json is a string (usually is), then "#{json_str}" should be exactly equal to json_str. If it isn't, that's a bug in ruby somehow (doubtful).
If you need the quotes, you need to either add them manually or escape the string using whatever escape function is appropriate for your use case. You could use .to_json as your escape function even ("#{json_str.to_json}", for example).
I have a string in R which escapes quotation marks:
my_text = {\"stim\":[\"platery\",\"denial\",\"generic\"]}
When using cat() I get:
{"stim":["platery","denial","generic"]}
Now my whole string is a JSON string that needs to be parsed and is evaluated invalid by JSONLint. If I copy&paste the cat() version, this is valid a JSON, so I think I just miss some pre-processing here.
I saw this SO post here, and this one, and this really good one, so I tried to replace the single quotation marks with double quotation marks for the JSON parser:
gsub("\\\\", "\\\\\\\\", my_text, fixed=TRUE)
but it did't change my string as I wanted. How can I change the string to become valid JSON?
As Wiktor said your gsub didn't work because you are attempting to replace backslashes, but there aren't any backslashes in your string. R is just using the backslashes as a way to store the double quotes. The third SO post you link does a good job explaining R's string literals which addresses this. A backslash in R is stored as a double backslash.
My first piece of advice would be to use the R package jsonlite to construct your JSON from an R object as opposed to a string if possible (heres the vignette).
Example:
myJSON <- jsonlite::toJSON(list(stim=c("platery","denial","generic")))
# {"stim":["platery","denial","generic"]}
Second, (as the third SO post again does a good job of explaining) copying/pasting the print method of the string may not be the best way to validate the JSON. I'm not sure of the use case, but R storing the double quotes with escape characters is probably not a bad thing.
If you want to get a prettier print method you can use numerous tricks in R (noquote(), cat(), print(quote=F)) but this won't change that R stores the double quotes with backslashes:
Additionally, in some cases constructing the JSON isn't necessary. I have an API built using the plumbr package that returns a list as JSON without any modifications (recJSON <- list(message=messages,recommendations=list(name=names, link=URLs)))
Here is my string
{
'user': {
'name': 'abc',
'fx': {
'message': {
'color': 'red'
},
'user': {
'color': 'blue'
}
}
},
'timestamp': '2013-10-04T08: 10: 41+0100',
'message': 'I'mABC..',
'nanotime': '19993363098581330'
}
Here the message contains single quotation mark, which is same as the quotation used in JSON. What I do is fill up a string from user inputs such as message. So, I need to escape those kind of special scenarios which breaks the code. But other than string replace, is there any way to make them escape but still allow HTML to process them back to the correct message?
I'm appalled by the presence of highly-upvoted misinformation on such a highly-viewed question about a basic topic.
JSON strings cannot be quoted with single quotes. The various versions of the spec (the original by Douglas Crockford, the ECMA version, and the IETF version) all state that strings must be quoted with double quotes. This is not a theoretical issue, nor a matter of opinion as the accepted answer currently suggests; any JSON parser in the real world will error out if you try to have it parse a single-quoted string.
Crockford's and ECMA's version even display the definition of a string using a pretty picture, which should make the point unambiguously clear:
The pretty picture also lists all of the legitimate escape sequences within a JSON string:
\"
\\
\/
\b
\f
\n
\r
\t
\u followed by four-hex-digits
Note that, contrary to the nonsense in some other answers here, \' is never a valid escape sequence in a JSON string. It doesn't need to be, because JSON strings are always double-quoted.
Finally, you shouldn't normally have to think about escaping characters yourself when programatically generating JSON (though of course you will when manually editing, say, a JSON-based config file). Instead, form the data structure you want to encode using whatever native map, array, string, number, boolean, and null types your language has, and then encode it to JSON with a JSON-encoding function. Such a function is probably built into whatever language you're using, like JavaScript's JSON.stringify, PHP's json_encode, or Python's json.dumps. If you're using a language that doesn't have such functionality built in, you can probably find a JSON parsing and encoding library to use. If you simply use language or library functions to convert things to and from JSON, you'll never even need to know JSON's escaping rules. This is what the misguided question asker here ought to have done.
A JSON string must be double-quoted, according to the specs, so you don't need to escape '.
If you have to use special character in your JSON string, you can escape it using \ character.
See this list of special character used in JSON :
\b Backspace (ascii code 08)
\f Form feed (ascii code 0C)
\n New line
\r Carriage return
\t Tab
\" Double quote
\\ Backslash character
However, even if it is totally contrary to the spec, the author could use \'.
This is bad because :
It IS contrary to the specs
It is no-longer JSON valid string
But it works, as you want it or not.
For new readers, always use a double quotes for your json strings.
Everyone is talking about how to escape ' in a '-quoted string literal. There's a much bigger issue here: single-quoted string literals aren't valid JSON. JSON is based on JavaScript, but it's not the same thing. If you're writing an object literal inside JavaScript code, fine; if you actually need JSON, you need to use ".
With double-quoted strings, you won't need to escape the '. (And if you did want a literal " in the string, you'd use \".)
Most of these answers either does not answer the question or is unnecessarily long in the explanation.
OK so JSON only uses double quotation marks, we get that!
I was trying to use JQuery AJAX to post JSON data to server and then later return that same information.
The best solution to the posted question I found was to use:
var d = {
name: 'whatever',
address: 'whatever',
DOB: '01/01/2001'
}
$.ajax({
type: "POST",
url: 'some/url',
dataType: 'json',
data: JSON.stringify(d),
...
}
This will escape the characters for you.
This was also suggested by Mark Amery, Great answer BTW
Hope this helps someone.
May be i am too late to the party but this will parse/escape single quote (don't want to get into a battle on parse vs escape)..
JSON.parse("\"'\"")
The answer the direct question:
To be safe, replace the required character with \u+4-digit-hex-value
Example:
If you want to escape the apostrophe ' replace with \u0027
D'Amico becomes D\u0027Amico
NICE REFERENCE:
http://es5.github.io/x7.html#x7.8.4
https://mathiasbynens.be/notes/javascript-escapes
Using template literals...
var json = `{"1440167924916":{"id":1440167924916,"type":"text","content":"It's a test!"}}`;
Use encodeURIComponent() to encode the string.
Eg.:
var product_list = encodeURIComponent(JSON.stringify(product_list));
You don't need to decode it since the web server automatically do the same.
To allow single quotes within doubule quoted string for the purpose of json, you double the single quote. {"X": "What's the question"} ==> {"X": "What''s the question"}
https://codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/69266/json-conversion-to-single-quotes
The \' sequence is invalid.
regarding AlexB's post:
\' Apostrophe or single quote
\" Double quote
escaping single quotes is only valid in single quoted json strings
escaping double quotes is only valid in double quoted json strings
example:
'Bart\'s car' -> valid
'Bart says \"Hi\"' -> invalid
I used SBJsonParser to parse a json string.
inside, instead of hebrew chars, I got a string full of chars in a form like \U05de
what would be the best way to decode these back to hebrew chars,
so i can put these on controls like UIFieldView?
Eventually I ran a loop iterating in the string for the chars \u
in the loop, when detected such a substring, i took a range of 6 characters since that index,
giving me a substring for example \u052v that need to be fixed.
on this string, i ran the method [str JSONValue], which gave me the correct char, then i simply replaced all occurrences of \u052v (for example) with the latter corrected char.