This question already has an answer here:
What is going on with MySQL integer field matching string?
(1 answer)
Closed 2 years ago.
I have a table name workspaces with id has data type = bigint(20) unsigned
I'm trying to query my database as the following:
SELECT * FROM workspaces WHERE id = 1;
SELECT * FROM workspaces WHERE id = '1.a';
Both of them are returns the correct result. But I think the (2) statement is wrong, why sql still return correct value right? What is the reason?
Could you help me to understand why? Thank you so much.
Here is test case on db<>fiddle.
MySQL has complex casting rules for what happens when you try to compare a string literal (e.g. 1.a) against an integer column (id). What is happening here is that MySQL is taking the leading numbers from the string and then forming a number based on that. As a result, the check becomes 1 = 1, which is true for that particular record which is being returned.
On most other databases, your second query would not even execute, which is generally all the better for you. You should not mix numeric and non numeric types in the same comparison.
It extracts the number from string.
For example "1.a"=1
I hope it helps.
In a situation where the sides of a comparison operator (= in this case) don't match, the database will do its best to convert one side the other's type. If there's absolutely no way of doing it, it will throw an error, but it still won't be a syntax error (since the query itself has a valid form), but some error about type conversion.
MySQL, specifically, notoriously plays fast and loose with type conversions. In the case of converting a character literal to a numeric type, if the string starts with a digit, it will convert the starting sequence of digits to a number and ignore anything after it.
Related
I am running a query on a db table which is returning one record when I expect it to return no records.
SELECT yeargroupID FROM tbl_yeargroup WHERE yeargroup='S' AND schoolID=2.
The yeargroup field is a tinyint field. Thefore the WHERE clause is looking the letter 'S' in the numeric field, so should not find anything. Yet it returns the record with the yeargroup = 0, and yeargroupID=17 (the bottom record in the table)
I'm confused as to why it is returning this record and how to avoid it.
Thanks
This logic, as you have pointed out, is comparing a number and a string:
WHERE yeargroup = 'S'
Handling such situations is an important part of most SQL compilers, and it is well documented. The solution is to implicitly convert values to "conforming" types. This is sad. My preference would be for the compiler to generate an error and force the user to use correct types. I find that implicit conversion creates more problems than it solves.
In any case, the rules in this case are pretty simple. The string is converted to an integer. But, how is a string with no digits converted? Well, the rule in MySQL is that the leading digits are converted to a number. And if there are none, the value is 0. So, this turns into:
where yeargroup = 0
You can see the results more clearly if you run:
select 'S', 'S' + 0
Note that most databases would return an error in this case (a type conversion error). But even those would accept the string if it looked like a number, so this would be allowed:
where yeargroup = '5'
What is the proper solution? Never mix types. Do not construct queries by munging constant values. Instead, queries from an application should always be using parameters.
The query executed should match the story_id with the provided string but when I execute the query it's giving me a wrong result. Please refer to the screenshot.
story_id column in your case is of INT (or numeric) datatype.
MySQL does automatic typecasting in this case. So, 5bff82... gets typecasted to 5 and thus you get the row corresponding to story_id = 5
Type Conversion in Expression Evaluation
When an operator is used with operands of different types, type
conversion occurs to make the operands compatible. Some conversions
occur implicitly. For example, MySQL automatically converts strings to
numbers as necessary, and vice versa.
Now, ideally your application code should be robust enough to handle this input. If you expect the input to be numeric only, then your application code can use validation operations on the data (to ensure that it is only a number, without typecasting) before sending it to MySQL server.
Another way would be to explicitly typecast story_id as string datatype and then perform the comparison. However this is not recommended approach as this would not be able to utilize Indexing.
SELECT * FROM story
WHERE (CAST story_id AS CHAR(12)) = '5bff82...'
If you run the above query, you would get no results.
you can also use smth like this:
SELECT * FROM story
WHERE regexp_like(story_id,'^[1-5]{1}(.*)$');
for any story_ids starting with any number and matching any no of charatcers after that it wont match with story_id=5;
AND if you explicitly want to match it with a string;
I have a table on my MySQL db named membertable. The table consists of two fields which are memberid and membername. The memberid field has the type of integer and uses auto_increment function starting from 2001. The membername table has the type of varchar.
The membertable has two records with the same order as described above. The records look like this :
memberid : 2001
membername : john smith
memberid : 2002
membername : will smith
I found something weird when I ran a SELECT statement against the memberid field. Running the following statement :
SELECT * FROM `membertable` WHERE `memberid` = '2001somecharacter'
It returned the first data.
Why did that happen? There's no record with memberid = 2001somecharacter. It looks like MySQL only search the first 4 character (2001) and when It's found related data, which is the returned data above, it denies the remaining characters.
How could this happen? And is there any way to turn off this behavior?
--
membertable uses innodb engine
This happens because mysql tries to convert "2001somecharacter" into a number which returns 2001.
Since you're comparing a number to a string, you should use
SELECT * FROM `membertable` WHERE CONVERT(`memberid`,CHAR) = '2001somecharacter';
to avoid this behavior.
OR to do it properly, is NOT put your search variable in quotes so that it has to be a number otherwise it'll blow up because of syntax error and then in front end making sure it's a number before passing in the query.
sqlfiddle
Your finding is an expexted MySQL behaviour.
MySQL converts a varchar to an integer starting from the beginning. As long as there are numeric characters wich can easily be converted, they are icluded in the conversion process. If there's a letter, the conversion stops returning the integer value of the numeric string read so far...
Here's some description of this behavior on the MySQL documentation Site. Unfortunately, it's not mentioned directly in the text, but there's an example which exactly shows this behaviour.
MySQL is very liberal in converting string values to numeric values when evaluated in numeric context.
As a demonstration, adding 0 causes the string to evaluated in a numeric context:
SELECT '2001foo' + 0 --> 2001
, '01.2-3E' + 0 --> 1.2
, 'abc567g' + 0 --> 0
When a string is evaluated in a numeric context, MySQL reads the string character by character, until it encounters a character where the string can no longer be interpreted as a numeric value, or until it reaches the end of the string.
I don't know of a way to "turn off" or disable this behavior. (There may be a setting of sql_mode that changes this behavior, but likely that change will impact other SQL statements that are working, which may stop working if that change is made.
Typically, this kind of check of the arguments is done in the application.
But if you need to do this in the SELECT statement, one option would be cast/convert the column as a character string, and then do the comparison.
But that can have some significant performance consequences. If we do a cast or convert (or any function) on a column that's in a condition in the WHERE clause, MySQL will not be able to use a range scan operation on a suitable index. We're forcing MySQL to perform the cast/convert operation on every row in the table, and compare the result to the literal.
So, that's not the best pattern.
If I needed to perform a check like that within the SQL statement, I would do something like this:
WHERE t.memberid = '2001foo' + 0
AND CAST('2001foo' + 0 AS CHAR) = '2001foo'
The first line is doing the same thing as the current query. And that can take advantage of a suitable index.
The second condition is converting the same value to a numeric, then casting that back to character, and then comparing the result to the original. With the values shown here, it will evaluate to FALSE, and the query will not return any rows.
This will also not return a row if the string value has a leading space, ' 2001'. The second condition is going to evaluate as FALSE.
When comparing an INT to a 'string', the string is converted to a number.
Converting a string to a number takes as many of the leading characters as it can and still be a number. So '2001character' is treated as the number 2001.
If you want non-numeric characters in member_id, make it VARCHAR.
If you want only numeric ids, then reject '200.1character'
I am playing with Multilldae's XSS exercise and in one of the exercise(OWASP 2013->A3->Reflected->Pen Test Tool Lookup) my crafted input lead to the following query. The where clause is in a very strange form. And tool_id is an int field.
SELECT tool_id, tool_name, phase_to_use, tool_type, comment FROM pen_test_tools
WHERE tool_id = '2\", \"good\":\"haha';
Surprising to me, this query successfully executes and returns the correct result. Could you please tell me why? In my view, the where clause is completely nonsense and MySQL should report an error.
Thanks!
The reason is because tool_id is an integer, so the comparison is done numerically.
MySQL will convert a string to a number in a numeric context. When it does so, it does
"silent" conversion, so errors are not reported. It converts a string based on the leading numbers, so this string becomes 2. If there are no leading digits (or minus signs or plus signs after leading spaces), then the value is 0.
This is more a "why" or "any pointers to documentations" question.
Today I realised that a comparison in WHERE clause takes only the first numerical part of the string if compared to an INT column. (My own conclusion)
For example:
SELECT * FROM companies c WHERE id = '817m5'
will still return companies with id = 817.
It does make sense but I'm failing to find this documented anywhere to see if my conclusion is correct and if there are additional things to know about this exact behaviour. WHERE, INT type, comparison documentation? Where? How is it called?
Thanks!
This is the comparison:
WHERE id = '817m5'
and id is an integer.
So, MySQL has to compare an integer to a string. Well, it can't do that directly. It either has to convert the string to a number or the number to the string. MySQL converts the string to a number, which it does by converting the leading numeric characters. So, the '817m5' becomes 817.
Here is the exact quote:
To cast a string to a numeric value in numeric context, you normally
do not have to do anything other than to use the string value as
though it were a number:
mysql> SELECT 1+'1'; -> 2