I want to make a demo application that is able to ask a user if he/she has followed the correct methods to build an item.
I have created a 'checklist' for the user to fill in as he/she builds the item. For example some of the questions could be:
Have you received the correct parts?
Are the parts in good condition?
Are you building a chair?
Do you have the correct specifications for the chair?
...
...
...
And so on...
So these questions have yes/no answers only. My plan was to create a table and call each column by the questions' number. So column 1 will be called '1' and it's the first question. Column 2 will be called '2' and it's the second question and so on.
So this table will be called Chair inspection. I then have another table called Table inspection with its own set of checklist questions.
This data is captured using an android application. The development of the application is done. Just need advice on the database part.
Is this the correct approach to storing the user's inputs?
I advice you have three tables, one for the questions, the other for the users who will be answering those questions and the last one is for the answers, then you establish the relationship between those three tables. That means Many users can answer many questions. Therefore there will be many to many relationship between users and questions. Then there will be relationship between questions and answers and answer with the users who responded to the questions.
I think that way you will be able to avoid redundancy and simplify the process of updating, and retrieving you data.
A normalised schema might be as follows (incomplete, and ignoring 'tables' for the time being) :
inspection
inspection_id* item inspected_by date
inspection_detail
inspection_id* checklist_id* status
* = (component of) PRIMARY KEY
I'm about to develop a database used for storing questionnaire with a indefinite number of questions. This database will communicate with a server, used for registering the answers and retrieving them when needed. For each user, I need to store the answer to each question, which is server-side mandatory.
The structure should be like that:
QUESTIONNAIRE:
Questionnaire n.1 (Question1,Question2,...,QuestionN)
Questionnaire n.2 (Question1,...,QuestionM)
...
USER:
User1
User2
...
ANSWERS
User1 - Questionnaire n.1 (AnswToQuestion1, AnswToQuestion2...AnswToQuestionN)
User2 - Questionnaire n.1 (AnswToQuestion1, AnswToQuestion2...AnswToQuestionN)
User2 - Questionnaire n.2 (AnswToQuestion1, AnswToQuestion2...AnswToQuestionM)
Given the specifications above, I face 2 major problems:
Indefinite number of questions means that a table must store each individual questions for each questionnaire
There should be a corrispondence between question and answer
I thought about 2 different solution for facing such problems, but I can really decide between the 2.
The first one would consist in creating 5 differents table, as follows:
The idea is basically to store users in USER table, and for each user store an ANSWER which refers to a specific questionnaire. This gives an information like 'user x has replied to questionnaire'. Then, the unique id id:ANSWER would be used to mark a given answer in MARKETINGANSWER. The QUESTIONNAIRE table would save each instance of a questionnaire, and provide an unique id to link each different question in the MARKETINGQUESTION table. At the end, the unique id id:MARKETINGQUESTION would be used to map a question to a given answer.
What does not convince me: this has too many layers of indirection. I do not like the forced connection of MARKETINGANSWER and MARKETINGQUESTION, yet I need a way to map them. Moreover, I need the general table for ANSWER, since it provides some general info about the questionnaire (the hidden columns).
Then I thougth about a second approach: creating an unique ANSWER and QUESTIONNAIRE table which would envelop in a TEXT attribute the series of answers/questions separated by a special escape character (such as #&, for instance). This would ruin the mapping, but it can be implemented in the web application - I was thinking about a control on the number of question/answer, the ordering would be ensured on questionnaire registration and commit on the database. Moreover, the schema would be cleaner. Yet, I would lose a consistent representation in the database schema.
I would like, if possible, some suggestion about the proposed solutions. I am pretty sure there is something simple I cannot quite grasp.
Thank you in advance.
I don't know much about programming so i created this database using Access.
This one is kinda tough for me to do.
There are few tables in the database. Employee ID and training they got and minutes.
What I want to know is a possible way to get training information relating to employee's past 3 years and input them into a single text-box named as previous visits where i can create the minute.
All these tables are linked by the Employee ID.
In my opinion, you could have some vba code to store the employee id
and then loop their training in the training table. The insert the
values into a tblEmployeeTrainingRecords table.
I'm working on a Reusable Survey database design. So the idea is.
A Client has many users, A client has categories which consist of questions. Every User has to answer all questions to complete the Survey. Those answers are stored in the Answers table.
The hard part
Some users are coaches, so a coach can fill in the survey for the user, thus providing a score on what they would answer in the place of the user. So we can later compare what the user answered and what the coach answered for each user. That's not to hard! The following is:
After some months we should be able to let the users redo the surveys, so with new answers to all the still existing questions.
I'm wondering if my db design is allright for this.
I have the feeling that this isn't optimal.
For example the following queries seem difficult with my design
For a given Scan, give me all categories and questions
(because of the many tables in between)
Looking very forward to your responses!
Think about how you are going to want to use this information. Are you going to want to compare users scores to coaches scores to their new scores? I think that is likely. Will they end up taking the survey multiple times if they don't improve enough? Are there going to be questions that do not have integer answers? How are you going to store those results? When they create a new survey are they going to want to reuse some previous questions or answers (like yes/no). How are you going to identify a unique user, names are not unique and autogenerated IDs are unique, but how will you know which John Smith belongs to which of the 12 ids you have?
I would rename the Answer table as SurveyResponse.
To it I would add the datetime of the surveyresponse (so people can
answer it multiple times and you can compare the answers) and a
Survey ID (from the new table in the next suggestion).
I would create a Survey table that stores the questions that belong
to a particular survey.
I would create a new Answer table that just has possible answers and
an ID.
I would create a table called SurveyQuestionAnswer which stores the
allowed answers to the question for each survey (different surveys
might have different possible responses to the same question).
this is a follow-up question on my previous one.We junior year students are doing website development for the univeristy as volunteering work.We are using PHP+MySQL technique.
Now I am mainly responsible for the database development using MySQL,but I am a MySQL designer.I am now asking for some hints on writing my first table,to get my hands on it,then I could work well with other tables.
The quesiton is like this,the first thing our website is going to do is to present a Survey to the user to collect their preference on when they want to use the bus service.
and this is where I am going to start my database development.
The User Requirement Document specifies that for the survey,there should be
Customer side:
Survery will be available to customers,with a set of predefined questions and answers and should be easy to fill out
Business side:
Survery info. will be stored,outputed and displayable for analysis.
It doesnt sound too much work,and I dont need to care about any PHP thing,but I am just confused on :should I just creat a single table called " Survery",or two tables "Survey_business" and "Survey_Customer",and how can the database store the info.?
I would be grateful if you guys could give me some help so I can work along,because the first step is always the hardest and most important.
Thanks.
I would use multiple tables. One for the surveys themselves, and another for the questions. Maybe one more for the answer options, if you want to go with multiple-choice questions. Another table for the answers with a record per question per answerer. The complexity escalates as you consider multiple types of answers (choice, fill-in-the-blank single-line, free-form multiline, etc.) and display options (radio button, dropdown list, textbox, yada yada), but for a simple multiple-choice example with a single rendering type, this would work, I think.
Something like:
-- Survey info such as title, publish dates, etc.
create table Surveys
(
survey_id number,
survey_title varchar2(200)
)
-- one record per question, associated with the parent survey
create table Questions
(
question_id number,
survey_id number,
question varchar2(200)
)
-- one record per multiple-choice option in a question
create table Choices
(
choice_id number,
question_id number,
choice varchar2(200)
)
-- one record per question per answerer to keep track of who
-- answered each question
create table Answers
(
answer_id number,
answerer_id number,
choice_id number
)
Then use application code to:
Insert new surveys and questions.
Populate answers as people take the surveys.
Report on the results after the survey is in progress.
You, as the database developer, could work with the web app developer to design the queries that would both populate and retrieve the appropriate data for each task.
only 1 table, you'll change only the way you use the table for each ocasion
customers side insert data into the table
business side read the data and results from the same table
Survey.Customer sounds like a storage function, while Survey.Business sounds like a retrieval function.
The only tables you need are for storage. The retrieval operations will take place using queries and reports of the existing storage tables, so you don't need additional tables for those.
Use a single table only. If you were to use two tables, then anytime you make a change you would in effect have to do everything twice. That's a big pain for maintenance for you and anyone else who comes in to do it in the future.
most of the advice/answers so far are applicable but make certain (unstated!) assumptions about your domain
try to make a logical model of the entities and attributes that are required to capture the requirements, examine the relationships, consider how the data will be used on both sides of the process, and then design the tables. Talk to the users, talk to the people that will be running the reports, talk to whoever is designing the user interface (screens and reports) to get the complete picture.
pay close attention the the reporting requirements, as they often imply additional attributes and entities not extant in the data-entry schema
i think 2 tables needed:
a survey table for storing questions and choices for answer. each survey will be stored in one row with a unique survey id
other table is for storing answers. i think its better to store each customers answer in one row with a survey id and a customer id if necessary.
then you can compute results and store them in a surveyResults view.
Is the data you're presenting as the questions and answers going to be dynamic? Is this a long-term project that's going to have questions swapped in and out? If so, you'll probably want to have the questions and answers in your database as well.
The way I'd do it would be to define your entities and figure out how to design your tables so relationships are straightforward. Sounds to me like you have three entities:
Question
Answer
Completed Survey
Just a sample elaboration of what Steven and Chris has mentioned above.
There are gonna be multiple tables, if there are gonna be multiple surveys, and each survey has a different set of questions, and if same user can take multiple surveys.
Customer Table with CustID as the primary key
Questions Table with a Question ID as the primary key. If a question cannot belong to more than one survey (a N:1 relationship), then can also have Survey ID (of table Survey table mentioned in point 3) as one of the values in the table.
But if a Survey to Question relationship is N:M, then
(SurveryID, QuestionID) would become a composite key for the SurveyTable, else it would just have the SurveyID with the high level details of the survey like description.
UserSurvey table which would contain (USerID, SurveryID, QuestionID, AnswerGiven)
[Note: if same user can take the same survey again and again, either the old survey has to be updated or the repeat attempts have to stored as another rows with some serial number)