How to do multiple joins when some tables are empty - mysql

Question

I am trying to append 'lookup data' to a main record text/description field so it looks something like this:
This is the Description Text
LookUpName1:
LookupValue1
LookupValueN
This worked fine with Inner Join like so
Select J.id, Concat('<b>LookUpName</b>:<br>',group_concat(F.LookUpValue SEPARATOR '<br>'))
from MainTable J Inner Join
LookUpTable L Inner Join
LookUpValuesTable F
On J.ID = L.JobID and F.ID = L.FilterID
Group by J.ID
However my goal is to add append multiple Lookup Tables and if I add them to this as Inner Joins I naturally just get those record where both/all the LookupTables have records.
On the other hand when I tried Join or Left Join I got an error on the Group by J.ID.
My goal is to append any of the existing Lookup Table values to all of the Description. Right now all I can achieve is returning appended descriptions which have ALL of the Lookup table values.

Answer 1

Your query would work if the on clauses were in the "right" place:
select J.id,
Concat('<b>LookUpName</b>:<br>', group_concat(F.LookUpValue separator '<br>'))
from MainTable J left join
LookUpTable L
on J.ID = L.JobID left join
LookUpValuesTable F
on F.ID = L.FilterID
group by J.ID;
The problem with your query is a MySQL (mis)feature. The on clause is optional for an inner join. Don't ask me why the MySQL designers thought inner join and cross join should be syntactically equivalent. Every other database requires an on clause for an inner join. It is easy enough to express a cross join using on 1=1.
However, the on clause is required for the left join, so when you switch to a left join, the compiler has a problem with the unorthodox syntax. The real problem is a missing on clause; this just happens to show up as "I wasn't expecting a group by yet." Using more traditional syntax with each join followed by an on should fix the problem.