Problems parsing / accessing nested JSON / Hashtable data via variables in Powershell - json

Question

I'm trying to dynamically parse & build-up a data structure of some incoming JSON files I'm to be supplied with (that'll be in non-standard structure) via Powershell to then process the data in those files & hand them over to the next step.
As part of that, I'm trying to build up the data structure of the JSON file into essentially a list of of data-paths for me to parse through & grab the data out of, so that I can cope with arrays, nested JSON objects and so on. So far so good.
Where I fall into some sort of Powershell peculiarity is in handling 2+ levels of depth via a variable. Let me give you a nice code-block to demonstrate the problem...
# Generate a Quick JSON file with different data types & levels
[object]$QuickJson = #'
{
"Name" : "I am a JSON",
"Version" : "1.2.3.4",
"SomeBool" : true,
"NULLValue" : null,
"ArrayOfVersions" : [1.0,2.0,3.0],
"MyInteger" : 69,
"NestedJSON" : {
"Version" : 5.0,
"IsReady" : false
},
"DoubleNestedJSON" : {
"FirstLevel" : 1,
"DataValue" : "I am at first nested JSON level!",
"Second_JSON_Level" : {
"SecondLevel" : 2,
"SecondDataValue" : "I am on the 2nd nested level"
}
}
}
'#
# Import our JSON file into Powershell
[object]$MyPSJson = ConvertFrom-Json -InputObject $QuickJson
# Two quick string variables to access our JSON data paths
[string]$ShortJsonPath = "Name"
[string]$NestedJsonPath = "NestedJson.Version"
# Long string to access a double-nested JSON object
[string]$LongNestedJsonPath = "DoubleNestedJSON.Second_JSON_Level.SecondDataValue"
# Both of these work fine
Write-Host ("JSON Name (Direct) ==> " + $MyPSJson.Name)
Write-Host ("JSON Name (via Variable) ==> " + $MyPSJson.$ShortJsonPath)
# The following way to access a single nested Json Path works fine
Write-Host ("Nested JSON Version (via direct path) ==> " + $MyPSJson.NestedJson.Version)
# And THIS returns an empty line / is where I fall afoul of something in Powershell
Write-Host ("Nested JSON Version (via variable) ==> " + $MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath)
# Other things I tried -- all returning an empty line / failing in effect
Write-Host ("Alternate Nested JSON Version ==> " + $($MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath))
Write-Host ("Alternate Nested JSON Version ==> " + $MyPSJson.$($NestedJsonPath))
Write-Host ("Alternate Nested JSON Version ==> " + $($MyPSJson).$($NestedJsonPath))
# Similarly, while THIS works...
$MyPSJson | select-object -Property NestedJSON
# This will fail / return me nothing
$MyPSJson | select-object -Property NestedJSON.Version
... in doing a bunch of research around this, I came across a suggestion to transform this into a Hashtable -- but that has the same problem, sadly. So with the above code-snippet, the following will transform the JSON object into a hashtable.
# Same problem with a hash-table if constructed from the JSON file...
[hashtable]$MyHash = #{}
# Populate $MyHash with the data from our quickie JSON file...
$QuickJson | get-member -MemberType NoteProperty | Where-Object{ -not [string]::IsNullOrEmpty($QuickJson."$($_.name)")} | ForEach-Object {$MyHash.add($_.name, $QuickJson."$($_.name)")}
# ... and even then -- $MyHash."$($NestedJsonPath)" -- fails, while a single level deep string works fine in the variable! :(
So it's pretty clear that I'm running into "something" of a Powershell internal logic problem, but I can't get Powershell to be overly helpful in WHY that is. Adding a '-debug' or similar in an attempt to increase verbosity hasn't helped shed light on this.
I suspect it's something akin to the items raised in this article here ( https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/heyscriptingguy/2011/10/16/dealing-with-powershell-hash-table-quirks/ ) but just specific with variables.
I've not had any luck in finding anything obvious in the Powershell language specification (3.0 still being the latest from here as far as I can tell -- https://www.microsoft.com/en-usdownload/details.aspx?id=36389 ) either. It may be in there, I may just miss it.
Any advice in how to get Powershell to play nice with this would be greatly appreciated. I'm not sure how / why Powershell is fine with a simple string but seems to have issues with a 'something.somethingelse' type string here.
Thank you.
Further notes & addenda to the original:
It seems there are several issues to attack. One is "dealing with a single nested level". The "quick fix" for that seems to be using "Invoke-Expression" to resolve the statement, so for instance (IMPORTANT - take note of the back-tick with the first variable!):
iex "`$MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath"
That use of Invoke-Expression also works with multi-nested situations:
iex "`$MyPSJson.$LongNestedJsonPath"
An alternative approach that was mentioned is the use of multiple select statements ... but I've not been able to get that to work with multi-nested objects (Powershell seems to not resolve those properly for some reason).
So for instance in this scenario:
($MyComp | select $_.DoubleNestedJSON | select FirstLevel)
Powershell returns
FirstLevel
----------
... instead of the actual data value. So - for now, it seems that selects won't work with multi-level nested objects due to Powershell apparently not resolving them?

Answer 1

When you write something like
$MyPSJson.Name
this will attempt to retrieve the member named Name from the object $MyPSJson. If there is no such member, you'll get $null.
Now, when you do that with variables for the member name:
$MyPSJson.$ShortJsonPath
this works pretty much identical in that the member with the name stored in $ShortJsonPath is looked up and its value retrieved. No surprises here.
When you try that with a member that doesn't exist on the object, such as
$MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath
# equivalent to
# $MyPSJson.'NestedJSON.Version'
you'll get $null, as detailed before. The . operator will only ever access a member of the exact object that is the result of its left-hand-side expression. It will never go through a member hierarchy in the way you seem to expect it to do. To be frank, I'm not aware of a language that works that way.
The reason it works with Invoke-Expression is, that you effectively converting the $NestedJsonPath string into part of an expression resulting in:
$MyPSJson.NestedJSON.Version
which Invoke-Expression then evaluates.
You can, of course, define your own function that works that way (and I'd much prefer that instead of using Invoke-Expression, a cmdlet that should rarely, if ever, used (heck, it's eval for PowerShell – few languages with eval advocate its use)):
function Get-DeepProperty([object] $InputObject, [string] $Property) {
$path = $Property -split '\.'
$obj = $InputObject
$path | %{ $obj = $obj.$_ }
$obj
}
PS> Get-DeepProperty $MyPSJson NestedJson.Version
5,0
You could even make it a filter, so you can use it more naturally on the pipeline:
filter Get-DeepProperty([string] $Property) {
$path = $Property -split '\.'
$obj = $_
$path | %{ $obj = $obj.$_ }
$obj
}
PS> $MyPSJson | Get-DeepProperty nestedjson.version
5,0

Answer 2

Why this doesn't work
When you provide the properties that you'd like within a string, like this
[string]$NestedJsonPath = "NestedJson.Version"
Powershell looks for a property called NestedJSon.Version. It's not actually traversing the properties, but looking for a string literal which contains a period. In fact, if I add a property like that to your JSON like so.
[object]$QuickJson = #'
{
"Name" : "I am a JSON",
"Version" : "1.2.3.4",
"SomeBool" : true,
"NULLValue" : null,
"ArrayOfVersions" : [1.0,2.0,3.0],
"MyInteger" : 69,
"NestedJSON.Version" : 69,
"NestedJSON" : {
"Version" : 5.0,
"IsReady" : false
}
}
I now get a value back, like so:
>$MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath
69
The best way to get your values back is to use two separate variables, like this.
$NestedJson = "NestedJson"
$property = "Version"
>$MyPSJson.$NestedJson.$property
5.0
Or, alternatively, you could use select statements, as seen in the original answer below.
$MyPSJson | select $_.NestedJSON | select Version
Version
-------
1.2.3.4
If you use multiple Select-Object statements, they'll discard the other properties and allow you to more easily drill down to the value you'd like.

Answer 3

I followed Joey's filter example. However, I found it did not support accessing arrays.
Sharing the code that I got to work for this. Hopefully it will help others as well. Awesome thread!
filter Get-DeepProperty([string] $Property) {
$path = $Property -split '\.'
$obj = $_
foreach($node in $path){
if($node -match '.*\[\d*\]'){
$keyPieces = $node -split ('\[')
$arrayKey = $keyPieces[0]
$arrayIndex = $keyPieces[1] -replace ('\]','')
$obj = $obj.$arrayKey[$arrayIndex]
} else {
$obj = $obj.$node
}
}
$obj
}
Example usage:
$path = "nested.nestedtwo.steps[2]"
$payload | Get-DeepProperty $path

Answer 4

I had the same problem, so I wrote a function that does the trick.
It enables accessing any level of the json by variable path (string):
function getNestedJsonValue() {
param(
[Parameter(Mandatory = $true, ValueFromPipeline)] [PSCustomObject] $inputObj,
[Parameter(Mandatory = $true)] [string] $valuePath
)
if (($valuePath -eq $null) -or ($valuePath.length -eq 0) -or ($inputObj -eq $null)) {
return $inputObj
}
[System.Array] $nodes = "$valuePath" -split '\.'
foreach ($node in $nodes) {
if (($node -ne $null) -and ($node.length -gt 0) -and ($inputObj -ne $null)) {
$inputObj = $inputObj.$node
} else {
return $inputObj
}
}
return $inputObj
}
Usage: getNestedJsonValue -valuePath $nestedValuePath -inputObj $someJson
Pipe usage: $someJson | getNestedJsonValue -valuePath $nestedValuePath
An example nestedValuePath would be $nestedValuePath="some.nested.path"

Answer 5

Credit to wOxxOm for getting things on the right track.
Invoke-Expression does seem to work perfectly for this situation (if somewhat expensive, but that's fine in my personal example & situation), and it can cope with multiple levels of nesting.
So as examples for the above code snippet, the following will resolve just fine (Key point - pay attention to the initial back-tick. That caught me off guard):
Write-Host ("Single level JSON test ==> " + (iex "`$MyPSJson.$NestedJsonPath"))
Write-Host ("Double level JSON test ==> " + (iex "`$MyPSJson.$LongNestedJsonPath"))
That'll return our desired results:
Single level JSON test ==> 5.0
Double level JSON test ==> I am on the 2nd nested level
FoxDeploy's answer of using multi-level selects doesn't seem to work with 2+ levels of nesting, unfortunately for some bizarre reason.
Using:
($MyPSJson | select $_.DoubleNestedJSON | select FirstLevel)
We get the following back from Powershell:
FirstLevel
----------
... it seems that Powershell doesn't resolve nested objects in its entirety? We get a similar results if we intentionally use something that doesn't exist:
($MyPSJson | select $_.DoubleNestedJSON | select Doesnotexist)
... also simply returns:
Doesnotexist
------------
So - for now - it seems as if "Invoke-Expression" works most reliably (and most easily, as it's just a case of handing it a variable with the path'ed string).
I still can't explain the WHY of any of this so far (since I've used 'dotwalk'-ing with multiple variables through arrays quite happily), but at least there's a solution for now ... and that is Invoke-Expression !
The best (/least bad?) explanations for Invoke-Expression I've found so far are here (Microsoft's own description of the cmdlet doesn't really make a great job of hinting that it'd help in situations such as this):
http://ss64.com/ps/invoke-expression.html
https://www.adminarsenal.com/powershell/invoke-expression/