Is prefix scan CUDA sample code in gpugems3 correct? - cuda

Question

I've written a piece of code to call the kernel in the book GPU Gems 3, Chapter 39: Parallel Prefix Sum (Scan) with CUDA.
However the results that I get are a bunch of negative numbers instead of prefix scan.
Is my kernel call wrong or is there something wrong with the code from the GPU Gems 3 book?
Here is my code:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <sys/time.h>
#include <cuda.h>
__global__ void kernel(int *g_odata, int *g_idata, int n, int dim)
{
extern __shared__ int temp[];// allocated on invocation
int thid = threadIdx.x;
int offset = 1;
temp[2*thid] = g_idata[2*thid]; // load input into shared memory
temp[2*thid+1] = g_idata[2*thid+1];
for (int d = n>>1; d > 0; d >>= 1) // build sum in place up the tree
{
__syncthreads();
if (thid < d)
{
int ai = offset*(2*thid+1)-1;
int bi = offset*(2*thid+2)-1;
temp[bi] += g_idata[ai];
}
offset *= 2;
}
if (thid == 0) { temp[n - 1] = 0; } // clear the last element
for (int d = 1; d < n; d *= 2) // traverse down tree & build scan
{
offset >>= 1;
__syncthreads();
if (thid < d)
{
int ai = offset*(2*thid+1)-1;
int bi = offset*(2*thid+2)-1;
int t = temp[ai];
temp[ai] = temp[bi];
temp[bi] += t;
}
}
__syncthreads();
g_odata[2*thid] = temp[2*thid]; // write results to device memory
g_odata[2*thid+1] = temp[2*thid+1];
}
void Initialize(int *h_in,int num_items)
{
int j;
for(j=0;j<num_items;j++)
h_in[j]=j;
printf(" input: ");
printf("\n\n");
}
int main(int argc, char** argv)
{
int num_items = 512;
int* h_in = new int[num_items];
// Initialize problem
Initialize(h_in, num_items);
int *d_in = NULL;
cudaMalloc((void**)&d_in, sizeof(int) * num_items);
if(cudaSuccess != cudaMemcpy(d_in, h_in, sizeof(int) * num_items, cudaMemcpyHostToDevice)) fprintf(stderr,"could not copy to gpu");
// Allocate device output array
int *d_out = NULL;
cudaMalloc((void**)&d_out, sizeof(int) * (num_items+1));
kernel<<<1,256,num_items*sizeof(int)>>>(d_out, d_in,num_items, 2);
int* h_out= new int[num_items+1];
if(cudaSuccess != cudaMemcpy(h_out,d_out,sizeof(int)*(num_items+1),cudaMemcpyDeviceToHost))fprintf(stderr,"could not copy back");
int i;
printf(" \n");
for(i=0;i<num_items;i++)
printf(" ,%d ",h_out[i]);
// Cleanup
if (h_in) delete[] h_in;
if (h_out) delete[] h_out;
if (d_in) cudaFree(d_in);
if (d_out) cudaFree(d_out);
printf("\n\n");
return 0;
}

Answer 1

It seems that you've made at least 1 error in transcribing the code from the GPU Gems 3 chapter into your kernel. This line is incorrect:
temp[bi] += g_idata[ai];
it should be:
temp[bi] += temp[ai];
When I make that one change to the code you have now posted, it seems to print out the correct (exclusive-scan) prefix sum for me. There's a few other things I would mention:
Even without that change, I get some results that are close to correct. So if you're getting widely different stuff (e.g. negative numbers) you may have a problem with your machine setup or CUDA install. I would suggest using more rigorous cuda error checking than what you have now (although a machine setup problem should have been indicated in one of your checks.)
The routine as crafted will have some limitations. It can only be used in a single threadblock, it will have bank conflicts on shared memory access, and it will be limited in data set size to what can be handled by a single threadblock (this routine produces two output elements per thread, so the data set size is expected to be equal to twice the number of threads). As has been already covered, the dynamic shared memory allocation needs to be as large as the data set size (ie. twice the thread size, in number of elements).
This may be useful for learning, but if you want a robust, fast prefix scan, you are advised to use a routine from thrust or cub instead of your own code, even if derived from this (old) article.
The following code is similar to yours, but it has the above issues fixed, and I have templated the kernel for use with various datatypes:
#include <stdio.h>
#define DSIZE 512
#define cudaCheckErrors(msg) \
do { \
cudaError_t __err = cudaGetLastError(); \
if (__err != cudaSuccess) { \
fprintf(stderr, "Fatal error: %s (%s at %s:%d)\n", \
msg, cudaGetErrorString(__err), \
__FILE__, __LINE__); \
fprintf(stderr, "*** FAILED - ABORTING\n"); \
exit(1); \
} \
} while (0)
typedef int mytype;
template <typename T>
__global__ void prescan(T *g_odata, T *g_idata, int n)
{
extern __shared__ T temp[]; // allocated on invocation
int thid = threadIdx.x;
int offset = 1;
temp[2*thid] = g_idata[2*thid]; // load input into shared memory
temp[2*thid+1] = g_idata[2*thid+1];
for (int d = n>>1; d > 0; d >>= 1) // build sum in place up the tree
{
__syncthreads();
if (thid < d)
{
int ai = offset*(2*thid+1)-1;
int bi = offset*(2*thid+2)-1;
temp[bi] += temp[ai];
}
offset *= 2;
}
if (thid == 0) { temp[n - 1] = 0; } // clear the last element
for (int d = 1; d < n; d *= 2) // traverse down tree & build scan
{
offset >>= 1;
__syncthreads();
if (thid < d)
{
int ai = offset*(2*thid+1)-1;
int bi = offset*(2*thid+2)-1;
T t = temp[ai];
temp[ai] = temp[bi];
temp[bi] += t;
}
}
__syncthreads();
g_odata[2*thid] = temp[2*thid]; // write results to device memory
g_odata[2*thid+1] = temp[2*thid+1];
}
int main(){
mytype *h_i, *d_i, *h_o, *d_o;
int dszp = (DSIZE)*sizeof(mytype);
h_i = (mytype *)malloc(dszp);
h_o = (mytype *)malloc(dszp);
if ((h_i == NULL) || (h_o == NULL)) {printf("malloc fail\n"); return 1;}
cudaMalloc(&d_i, dszp);
cudaMalloc(&d_o, dszp);
cudaCheckErrors("cudaMalloc fail");
for (int i = 0 ; i < DSIZE; i++){
h_i[i] = i;
h_o[i] = 0;}
cudaMemset(d_o, 0, dszp);
cudaCheckErrors("cudaMemset fail");
cudaMemcpy(d_i, h_i, dszp, cudaMemcpyHostToDevice);
cudaCheckErrors("cudaMemcpy 1 fail");
prescan<<<1,DSIZE/2, dszp>>>(d_o, d_i, DSIZE);
cudaDeviceSynchronize();
cudaCheckErrors("kernel fail");
cudaMemcpy(h_o, d_o, dszp, cudaMemcpyDeviceToHost);
cudaCheckErrors("cudaMemcpy 2 fail");
mytype psum = 0;
for (int i =1; i < DSIZE; i++){
psum += h_i[i-1];
if (psum != h_o[i]) {printf("mismatch at %d, was: %d, should be: %d\n", i, h_o[i], psum); return 1;}
}
return 0;
}