How to make a query to GROUP BY x DESC - mysql

Question

The following SELECT statement
select *
from messages
where receiverID = '5'
group BY senderID
order by id DESC
database:
id | senderID | receiverID | message
1 | 245 | 5 | test 1
2 | 89 | 5 | test 2
3 | 79 | 5 | test 3
4 | 245 | 5 | test 4
5 | 245 | 5 | test 5
For senderID=245 I expected to return the row with id=5 , but it dosent it returns row with id=1, but i want the last row. How to achieve that ?
returns:
id | senderID | receiverID | message
1 | 245 | 5 | test 1
2 | 89 | 5 | test 2
3 | 79 | 5 | test 3
Ohh I made it :D
so this is the code that worked,for anyone with similar question
SELECT * FROM ( SELECT * FROM messages WHERE
receiverID = '5' ORDER BY id DESC) AS m GROUP BY senderID ORDER BY id DESC

Answer 1

This is not possible. You have to do something like:
[...] WHERE `id` = (SELECT MAX(`id`) FROM `messages` WHERE `receiverID` = '5')

Answer 2

Personally I'd consider a subquery, something along the lines of this should do the job for you
SELECT messagesOrdered.*
FROM (
SELECT *
FROM messages
WHERE receiverID = '5'
ORDER BY id DESC
) AS messagesOrdered
GROUP BY senderID
You may wish to check what keys you have set up depending on how large the table is.
The problem with using MAX is that if you use MAX on the id field then it will get the number you are looking for, however using MAX on another field does not get the data that matches that id. Using the subquery method, the inner query is doing the sorting and then the GROUP on the outside will group based on the order of rows in the inner query.

Answer 3

SELECT * FROM messages m
JOIN
( SELECT senderID, MAX(id) AS last
FROM messages
WHERE receiverID = '5'
GROUP BY senderID ) mg
ON m.id = mg.last

Answer 4

Not sure I understand your question completely, but it sounds to me like you want:
select max(id),
senderId,
max(receiverId),
max(message)
from messages
where receiverID = '5'
group BY senderID
order by id DESC
Note that you need to include message into your aggregate as well, otherwise you'll get unpredicatable results (other DBMS wouldn't allow leaving out the max(message) but MySQL will simply return a random row from the group).

Answer 5

Here it goes mine :)
select m1.* from messages m1
left join messages m2
on m1.senderid = m2.senderid and m1.id < m2.id
where m2.id is null and receiverID = '5'
Given your example this would return:
+----+----------+------------+---------+
| ID | SENDERID | RECEIVERID | MESSAGE |
+----+----------+------------+---------+
| 2 | 89 | 5 | test 2 |
| 3 | 79 | 5 | test 3 |
| 5 | 245 | 5 | test 5 |
+----+----------+------------+---------+