'Invalid Handle object' when using a timer inside a function in MatLab - function

Question

I am using a script in MatLab that works perfectly fine by itself, but I need to make a function out of it.
The script read a .csv file, extract all values, start a timer, and at each tick displays the corresponding coordinates extracted from the .csv, resulting in a 3D animation of my graph.
What I would like is to give it the location of the .csv, so that it starts displaying the graphs for this csv.
Here is what I have come up with:
function handFig(fileLoc)
csv=csvread(fileLoc,1,0);
both = csv(:,2:19);
ax=axes;
set(ax,'NextPlot','replacechildren');
Dt=0.1; %sampling period in secs
k=1;
hp1=text(both(k,1),both(k,2),both(k,3),'thumb'); %get handle to dot object
hold on;
hp2=text(both(k,4),both(k,5),both(k,6),'index');
hp3=text(both(k,7),both(k,8),both(k,9),'middle');
hp4=text(both(k,10),both(k,11),both(k,12),'ring');
hp5=text(both(k,13),both(k,14),both(k,15),'pinky');
hp6=text(both(k,16),both(k,17),both(k,18),'HAND');
L1=plot3([both(k,1),both(k,16)],[both(k,2),both(k,17)],[both(k,3),both(k,18)]);
L2=plot3([both(k,4),both(k,16)],[both(k,5),both(k,17)],[both(k,6),both(k,18)]);
L3=plot3([both(k,7),both(k,16)],[both(k,8),both(k,17)],[both(k,9),both(k,18)]);
L4=plot3([both(k,10),both(k,16)],[both(k,11),both(k,17)],[both(k,12),both(k,18)]);
L5=plot3([both(k,13),both(k,16)],[both(k,14),both(k,17)],[both(k,15),both(k,18)]);
hold off;
t1=timer('TimerFcn','k=doPlot(hp1,hp2,hp3,hp4,hp5,hp6,L1,L2,L3,L4,L5,both,t1,k)','Period', Dt,'ExecutionMode','fixedRate');
start(t1);
end
And the doplot function used:
function k=doPlot(hp1,hp2,hp3,hp4,hp5,hp6,L1,L2,L3,L4,L5,pos,t1,k)
k=k+1;
if k<5000%length(pos)
set(hp1,'pos',[pos(k,1),pos(k,2),pos(k,3)]);
axis([0 255 0 255 0 255]);
set(hp2,'pos',[pos(k,4),pos(k,5),pos(k,6)]);
set(hp3,'pos',[pos(k,7),pos(k,8),pos(k,9)]);
set(hp4,'pos',[pos(k,10),pos(k,11),pos(k,12)]);
set(hp5,'pos',[pos(k,13),pos(k,14),pos(k,15)]);
set(hp6,'pos',[pos(k,16),pos(k,17),pos(k,18)]);
set(L1,'XData',[pos(k,1),pos(k,16)],'YData',[pos(k,2),pos(k,17)],'ZData',[pos(k,3),pos(k,18)]);
set(L2,'XData',[pos(k,4),pos(k,16)],'YData',[pos(k,5),pos(k,17)],'ZData',[pos(k,6),pos(k,18)]);
set(L3,'XData',[pos(k,7),pos(k,16)],'YData',[pos(k,8),pos(k,17)],'ZData',[pos(k,9),pos(k,18)]);
set(L4,'XData',[pos(k,10),pos(k,16)],'YData',[pos(k,11),pos(k,17)],'ZData',[pos(k,12),pos(k,18)]);
set(L5,'XData',[pos(k,13),pos(k,16)],'YData',[pos(k,14),pos(k,17)],'ZData',[pos(k,15),pos(k,18)]);
else
k=1;
set(hp1,'pos',[pos(k,1),pos(k,2),pos(k,3)]);
axis([0 255 0 255 0 255]);
set(hp2,'pos',[pos(k,4),pos(k,5),pos(k,6)]);
set(hp3,'pos',[pos(k,7),pos(k,8),pos(k,9)]);
set(hp4,'pos',[pos(k,10),pos(k,11),pos(k,12)]);
set(hp5,'pos',[pos(k,13),pos(k,14),pos(k,15)]);
set(hp6,'pos',[pos(k,16),pos(k,17),pos(k,18)]);
end
However, when I run handFig('fileName.csv'), I obtain the same error everytime:
??? Error while evaluating TimerFcn for timer 'timer-7'
Invalid handle object.
I figured that it might come from the function trying to create a new 'csv' and 'both' everytime, so I tried removing them, and feeding the function the data directly, without results.
What is exactly the problem? Is there a solution?
Thanks a lot!

Answer 1

I think it's because when you call doPlot in the timer for the first time, you pass in t1 as an argument, and it might not exist the first time.
Does doPlot need t1 at all? I'd suggest modifying it so it's not used, and then your call to:
t1=timer('TimerFcn','k=doPlot(hp1,hp2,hp3,hp4,hp5,hp6,L1,L2,L3,L4,L5,both,k)','Period', Dt,'ExecutionMode','fixedRate');
Note the missing t1 in the doPlot call.
Either that, or initialise your t1 before you create the timer so it has some value to pass in.
Update (as an aside, can you use pause(Dct) in a loop instead? seems easier)
Actually, now I think it's a problem of scope.
It took a bit of digging to get to this, but looking at the Matlab documentation for function callbacks, it says:
When MATLAB evaluates function handles, the same variables are in scope as when the function handle was created. (In contrast, callbacks specified as strings are evaluated in the base workspace.)
You currently give your TimerFcn argument as a string, so k=doPlot(...) is evaluated in the base workspace. If you were to go to the matlab prompt, run handFig, and then type h1, you'd get an error because h1 is not available in the global workspace -- it's hidden inside handFig.
That's the problem you're running into.
However, the workaround is to specify your function as a function handle rather than a string (it says function handles are evaluated in the scope in which they are created, ie within handFig).
Function handles to TimerFcn have to have two arguments obj and event (see Creating Callback Functions). Also, that help file says you have to put doPlot in its own m-file to have it not evaluate in the base Matlab workspace.
In addition to these two required input arguments, your callback
function can accept application-specific arguments. To receive these
input arguments, you must use a cell array when specifying the name of
the function as the value of a callback property. For more
information, see Specifying the Value of Callback Function Properties.
It goes through an example of what you have to do to get this working. Something like:
% create timer
t = timer('Period', Dt,'ExecutionMode','fixedRate');
% attach `k` to t so it can be accessed within doPlot
set(t,'UserData',k);
% specify TimerFcn and its extra arguments:
t.TimerFcn = { #doPlot, hp1, hp2, hp3, ...., both };
start(t)
Note -- the reason k is set in UserData is because it needs to be somehow saved and modified between calls to doPlot.
Then modify your doPlot to have two arguments at the beginning (which aren't used), and not accept the k argument. To extract k you do get(timer_obj,'UserData') from within doPlot:
function k=doPlot(timer_obj, event, hp1,hp2,hp3,.....)
k = get(timer_obj,'UserData');
.... % rest of code here.
% save back k so it's changed for next time!
set(timer_obj,'UserData',k);
I think that's on the right track - play around with it. I'd highly recommend the mathworks forums for this sort of thing too, those people are whizzes.
This thread from the mathworks forum was what got me started and might prove helpful to you.
Good luck!