Using GROUP_CONCAT on subquery in MySQL - mysql

Question

I have a MySQL query in which I want to include a list of ID's from another table. On the website, people are able to add certain items, and people can then add those items to their favourites. I basically want to get the list of ID's of people who have favourited that item (this is a bit simplified, but this is what it boils down to).
Basically, I do something like this:
SELECT *,
GROUP_CONCAT((SELECT userid FROM favourites WHERE itemid = items.id) SEPARATOR ',') AS idlist
FROM items
WHERE id = $someid
This way, I would be able to show who favourited some item, by splitting the idlist later on to an array in PHP further on in my code, however I am getting the following MySQL error:
1242 - Subquery returns more than 1 row
I thought that was kind of the point of using GROUP_CONCAT instead of, for example, CONCAT? Am I going about this the wrong way?
Ok, thanks for the answers so far, that seems to work. However, there is a catch. Items are also considered to be a favourite if it was added by that user. So I would need an additional check to check if creator = userid. Can someone help me come up with a smart (and hopefully efficient) way to do this?
Thank you!
Edit: I just tried to do this:
SELECT [...] LEFT JOIN favourites ON (userid = itemid OR creator = userid)
And idlist is empty. Note that if I use INNER JOIN instead of LEFT JOIN I get an empty result. Even though I am sure there are rows that meet the ON requirement.

Answer 1

OP almost got it right. GROUP_CONCAT should be wrapping the columns in the subquery and not the complete subquery (I'm dismissing the separator because comma is the default):
SELECT i.*,
(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(userid) FROM favourites f WHERE f.itemid = i.id) AS idlist
FROM items i
WHERE i.id = $someid
This will yield the desired result and also means that the accepted answer is partially wrong, because you can access outer scope variables in a subquery.

Answer 2

You can't access variables in the outer scope in such queries (can't use items.id there). You should rather try something like
SELECT
items.name,
items.color,
CONCAT(favourites.userid) as idlist
FROM
items
INNER JOIN favourites ON items.id = favourites.itemid
WHERE
items.id = $someid
GROUP BY
items.name,
items.color;
Expand the list of fields as needed (name, color...).

Answer 3

I think you may have the "userid = itemid" wrong, shouldn't it be like this:
SELECT ITEMS.id,GROUP_CONCAT(FAVOURITES.UserId) AS IdList
FROM FAVOURITES
INNER JOIN ITEMS ON (ITEMS.Id = FAVOURITES.ItemId OR FAVOURITES.UserId = ITEMS.Creator)
WHERE ITEMS.Id = $someid
GROUP BY ITEMS.ID

Answer 4

The purpose of GROUP_CONCAT is correct but the subquery is unnecessary and causing the problem. Try this instead:
SELECT ITEMS.id,GROUP_CONCAT(FAVOURITES.UserId)
FROM FAVOURITES INNER JOIN ITEMS ON ITEMS.Id = FAVOURITES.ItemId
WHERE ITEMS.Id = $someid
GROUP BY ITEMS.ID

Answer 5

Yes, soulmerge's solution is ok. But I needed a query where I had to collect data from more child tables, for example:
main table: sessions (presentation sessions) (uid, name, ..)
1st child table: events with key session_id (uid, session_uid, date, time_start, time_end)
2nd child table: accessories_needed (laptop, projector, microphones, etc.) with key session_id (uid, session_uid, accessory_name)
3rd child table: session_presenters (presenter persons) with key session_id (uid, session_uid, presenter_name, address...)
Every Session has more rows in child tables tables (more time schedules, more accessories)
And I needed to collect in one collection for every session to display in ore row (some of them):
session_id | session_name | date | time_start | time_end | accessories | presenters
My solution (after many hours of experiments):
SELECT sessions.uid, sessions.name,
,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT( `events`.date SEPARATOR '</li><li>')
FROM `events`
WHERE `events`.session_id = sessions.uid ORDER BY `events`.date) AS date
,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT( `events`.time_start SEPARATOR '</li><li>')
FROM `events`
WHERE `events`.session_id = sessions.uid ORDER BY `events`.date) AS time_start
,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT( `events`.time_end SEPARATOR '</li><li>')
FROM `events`
WHERE `events`.session_id = sessions.uid ORDER BY `events`.date) AS time_end
,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT( accessories.name SEPARATOR '</li><li>')
FROM accessories
WHERE accessories.session_id = sessions.uid ORDER BY accessories.name) AS accessories
,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT( presenters.name SEPARATOR '</li><li>')
FROM presenters
WHERE presenters.session_id = sessions.uid ORDER BY presenters.name) AS presenters
FROM sessions
So no JOIN or GROUP BY needed.
Another useful thing to display data friendly (when "echoing" them):
you can wrap the events.date, time_start, time_end, etc in "<UL><LI> ... </LI></UL>" so the "<LI></LI>" used as separator in the query will separate the results in list items.
I hope this helps someone. Cheers!